Skip to main content
Best Property Management Company in Fleming Island, FL: 2027 Comparison Guide

Best Property Management Company in Fleming Island, FL: 2027 Comparison Guide

By Cool Realty LLC Editorial Team | Updated for 2027 | Company details and market data checked November 16, 2026

The best property management company in Fleming Island, FL is the one that fits your home and your HOA, and puts its fees, services and contract terms in writing. No independent organization ranks property managers in Fleming Island.

Compare two or three companies on rental pricing, tenant screening, HOA lease approvals, inspection schedule, response time and total first-year cost. Companies that publish Fleming Island pages include Cool Realty LLC, Belong and PMI Davis Realty, and what each publishes about fees, screening and inspections differs a lot, as the comparison below shows.

Fleming Island is an unincorporated community in Clay County on the west bank of the St. Johns River, with Doctors Lake to the north and US 17 running through it. Most rentals are individually owned single-family homes, many of them former owner-occupied homes inside planned communities with HOAs. That shapes what owners need from a manager: someone who prices from leased homes nearby, follows the community's leasing rules and keeps a well-kept home in the condition the neighborhood expects.

This guide is for Fleming Island landlords, including owners who relocated, military families on new orders and first-time landlords. It covers the local rental market, what each company publishes, what management costs, a scorecard and the questions to ask before you sign.

Own a rental home in Fleming Island? Find out what it could rent for and whether professional management makes sense. Call Cool Realty at (904) 602-5555 for a Free Rental Analysis, or visit our Fleming Island property management page.

Disclosure: this guide is published by Cool Realty LLC, one of the companies compared. Company details come from each company's own website or profile as of November 16, 2026.

Why Do Fleming Island Owners Hire a Property Manager?

Most Fleming Island owners hire a manager to keep the home rented, protect it and handle the HOA and Florida legal steps they don't have time for. These are the usual triggers:

Owner situationWhat it costs if handled poorlyWhat a manager does
Relocation or military ordersNo one local for showings, repairs or emergenciesLocal leasing, maintenance and inspections; one point of contact
HOA communityFines or lease delays if tenants or leases don't follow the rulesTracks leasing rules, approvals and tenant compliance
VacancyAbout $2,035 of lost rent per month at the ZIP's three-bedroom averagePrices from leased comparables and lists quickly
ScreeningLate rent, damage or evictionApplies written criteria to every adult applicant
Late rentMissed notice deadlines delay recoveryOnline payments, late notices and Florida-compliant steps
RepairsNight and weekend calls; vendor shoppingEmergency line, vendors and approval limits

What Should Fleming Island Owners Know About the Rental Market?

Fleming Island is mostly owner-occupied, with higher home values and rents than Clay County overall, and asking rents dipped slightly over the past year. Accurate pricing matters more when rents aren't rising.

Zillow rental data, ZIP 32003Figure
Average asking rent (all property types)$2,200 / month
Change over 12 monthsDown about $84
Average two-bedroom rent$1,575 / month
Average three-bedroom rent$2,035 / month
Rentals listed at the time51
Data updatedNov. 9, 2026

Source: Zillow Rental Manager market trends for ZIP 32003. With about 50 listings, a few high-end homes can move averages; the four-bedroom average was left out for that reason.

U.S. Census Bureau, Fleming Island CDPFigure
Population (2020 Census)29,142
Owner-occupied housing rate (2020–2024)85.3%
Median value of owner-occupied homes (2020–2024)$422,400
Median gross rent (2020–2024)$1,935

Source: U.S. Census Bureau QuickFacts. Census median rent covers all existing leases over five years, so it runs below current asking rents.

Two local checks matter before you lease. Many Fleming Island homes are in planned communities, such as Eagle Harbor, Pace Island and Fleming Island Plantation, whose HOA documents can set minimum lease terms, tenant registration or fees, so read the declaration and rules first. And for homes near the St. Johns River, Doctors Lake or creeks, check the FEMA flood map: Florida landlords must give a written flood disclosure for leases of a year or longer (§83.512).

Where a property manager helps: with only about 50 rentals listed at a time, one overpriced home stands out. A manager prices from recently leased homes in the same community, not citywide averages.

Property Management Companies Serving Fleming Island, FL: 2027 Comparison

These companies publish pages or profiles about managing rentals in Fleming Island. They're listed alphabetically; this is not a ranking. Where a company doesn't publish a detail, the table says so. That doesn't mean the company lacks it; ask for it in writing.

CompanyOffice (as published)ModelPublished feesPublished guarantees / terms
BelongNo local office listed; Jacksonville-area phoneNational, tech-basedRent between residents listed at 1.75% of rent; other fees not publicly confirmedYear-long guaranteed rent with eviction costs covered (terms apply); placement fee waived if renting takes over 60 days
Cool Realty LLC1857 Wells Rd #207, Orange Park; no Fleming Island officeLocal full-service and tenant placement only10% monthly from month two; 9% for active-duty and retired military; $0 while vacant; $350 onboarding at signing and $400 at tenant placementCancel without penalty if no lease after 90 days of active advertising; 60-day cancellation after a completed lease that isn't renewed
HomeRiver GroupOrange Park page lists no Fleming Island service areaNational with a Jacksonville-area team"Pricing starts at 5%," per its Awning listing for Fleming Island; fee basis not publicly confirmedSays eviction assistance is included in the monthly fee
PMI Davis RealtyFleming Island (ZIP 32003), per its Thumbtack profile; no website listedLocal broker; full-service and tenant placement onlyNot publicly confirmedNot publicly confirmed

Sources: Cool Realty's Fleming Island page; Belong's Fleming Island page; HomeRiver Group's Orange Park page and its Awning listing; PMI Davis Realty's Thumbtack profile. All checked Nov. 16, 2026. Fees and terms change; confirm everything in a written proposal.

What the comparison shows

  • No company in this list has a dedicated Fleming Island office with published fees. The local broker publishes no fees; the companies that publish fees operate from Orange Park or nationally.
  • Fee structures differ more than the headline percentage. A low monthly rate can come with separate placement, renewal or service charges; compare the total first-year cost.
  • Guarantees vary. A rent guarantee, a no-lease cancellation right and eviction assistance are very different promises. Read the limits in the agreement.
  • Inspection frequency is rarely published. Of the companies listed, Cool Realty publishes a six-month schedule. Ask every company.

Want a side-by-side quote? Ask Cool Realty for a written fee breakdown and Free Rental Analysis for your Fleming Island home. Call (904) 602-5555.

How Do You Choose the Right Property Manager in Fleming Island?

Ask every company the same questions and compare written answers. These areas matter most in Fleming Island.

Property manager documenting a rental home kitchen during a routine inspection

HOA leasing rules and approvals

Ask: Have you managed homes in my community? How do you handle tenant registration, approvals, gate access and HOA violation notices?

Look for: A process that starts before the lease is signed, and a lease that requires tenants to follow association rules. Florida limits how rental restrictions adopted after July 1, 2021 apply to owners who already held title (§720.306(1)(h)), but rules already recorded still apply.

Rental pricing and marketing

Ask: Which leased homes will you compare mine to? Where will it be advertised, and how fast after it's ready?

Look for: A written rental analysis based on recently leased homes in ZIP 32003, professional photos and broad listing distribution.

Tenant screening

Ask: What are your written screening criteria, and do they apply to every adult applicant?

Look for: Credit, verified income, eviction history and landlord references, applied the same way to everyone under fair-housing law. See Cool Realty's tenant screening process.

Maintenance, inspections and storms

Ask: Who answers after hours? What can you spend without my approval? How often do you inspect, and what happens before and after a storm?

Look for: A 24-hour line, licensed and insured vendors, a written approval limit, scheduled inspections with photos and a storm process. See Cool Realty's maintenance services.

Military owners and tenants

Ask: Do you offer any military pricing or PCS hand-off support? How do your leases handle a tenant's military orders?

Look for: Leases that reflect Florida's servicemember termination rule (§83.682), which lets a tenant with qualifying orders end a lease with at least 30 days' written notice.

Scorecard: compare up to three managers

Score 1 (weak) to 5 (strong)Company ACompany BCompany C
Rental analysis used leased homes in ZIP 32003


HOA approval process explained


Written screening criteria provided


Inspection schedule and photo reports


After-hours and storm process explained


Full fee schedule and sample agreement provided


Total


How Much Do Property Managers Charge in Fleming Island?

Among companies that publish fees for Fleming Island, the monthly management fee is commonly about 10% of rent, plus one-time fees for onboarding, placement, lease preparation and renewal. The structure varies more than the percentage.

Fee typeWhat it coversCool Realty (as published)Question to ask every company
Monthly managementOngoing management after move-in10% from month two; 9% active-duty and retired militaryCharged on rent collected or rent due?
VacancyCharges while empty$0Anything charged while vacant?
OnboardingSetup, photos, initial marketing$350 at signingRefundable? What's included?
Tenant placementShowings, screening, lease signing$400 once placedCharged for every new tenant?
Lease preparationLease drafting$65 (attorney-prepared)Is the lease attorney-prepared?
RenewalRenewing a tenant$350 bundle incl. inspectionWhat does renewal include?
HandymanSmall repairs$50/hour plus materialsAny markup on vendor invoices?
Eviction protectionOptional coverage$30/month, cancel anytimeWhat's covered and what isn't?

Cool Realty fees from its Fleming Island page, checked Nov. 16, 2026. Confirm current fees on the pricing page.

Worked example: first-year cost on a Fleming Island home

Using Zillow's $2,035 three-bedroom average for ZIP 32003, a tenant placed in month one and Cool Realty's published fees:

LineAmount
Monthly fee: 10% × $2,035 × 11 months$2,238.50
Onboarding$350
Tenant placement$400
Lease preparation$65
Estimated first-year total$3,053.50

Example only; renewal, repairs and optional services are extra. Ask every company for the same first-year calculation.

Compare that with vacancy: one empty month at $2,035 costs about as much as ten months of the monthly fee. See our property management cost guide for more on each fee type.

Is a Property Manager Worth It in Fleming Island?

For owners who live away, own more than one rental or don't want to handle tenants, HOA notices and Florida's legal deadlines, usually yes. Self-managing means pricing and marketing the home, screening applicants consistently, writing a Florida-compliant lease, holding the deposit correctly (§83.49), collecting rent, handling repairs at night and on weekends and following exact notice rules if rent is late.

If something goes wrong, the process runs through Clay County. Evictions are filed at the courthouse in Green Cove Springs, the tenant gets 5 business days to respond after service, and the Clay County Sheriff's Office charges $90 to execute a writ of possession. Owners who live away rarely want to manage that from a distance. Read our guides on self-managing vs. hiring a property manager and managing a rental from out of state.

Why Consider Cool Realty LLC for Your Fleming Island Rental?

Cool Realty LLC manages single-family homes, townhomes and condos in Fleming Island from its office at 1857 Wells Road in Orange Park, a short drive north on US 17. Here's what it publishes about its Fleming Island property management service:

AreaWhat Cool Realty publishes
ServicesFull-service management, tenant placement only and Home Watch for vacant homes; leasing in English or Spanish
MarketingRental analysis, make-ready, professional photos and multi-site advertising. See rental marketing.
ScreeningCredit, income verification, eviction history and current-landlord contact for every adult applicant
InspectionsEvery six months, included in the management fee, plus move-in and move-out
Maintenance24-hour on-call line, vendor management and an in-house handyman
Military9% management fee for active-duty and retired military; PCS hand-off support
TermsNo-lease, no-fee cancellation after 90 days of active advertising; 60-day cancellation after a completed lease that isn't renewed
Not managedApartment complexes and condos in buildings of three or more stories

Cool Realty also manages rentals in nearby Orange Park and across the Jacksonville area.

What Should You Ask Before Signing a Property Management Agreement?

  1. What will I pay in the first year, including every one-time fee?
  2. Is the monthly fee charged on rent collected or rent due, and from which month?
  3. Do you charge anything while the home is vacant?
  4. Have you managed homes in my HOA, and how do you handle approvals?
  5. What are your written screening criteria?
  6. How often do you inspect, and will I get photos?
  7. What can you spend on repairs without my approval?
  8. Who answers after hours, and what is your storm process?
  9. When will I receive rent and statements?
  10. How do I cancel, and what does it cost?
  11. What do your guarantees cover, and what are the limits?
  12. Which Florida real estate broker is responsible for my account?

You can verify a company's license with the Florida DBPR license search.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the best property management company in Fleming Island, FL?

There's no independent ranking. The best company for you fits your home and HOA and puts its fees, services and terms in writing. Companies with Fleming Island pages or profiles include Belong, Cool Realty and PMI Davis Realty; compare two or three with the same questions.

How much do property managers charge in Fleming Island?

Among companies that publish fees, about 10% of monthly rent is common, plus one-time fees such as onboarding, placement, lease preparation and renewal. Compare the total first-year cost from written quotes.

How much rent can I get for my Fleming Island home?

Zillow showed an average asking rent of $2,200 in ZIP 32003 in November 2026, with three-bedroom homes averaging $2,035. Your home's rent depends on size, condition and community; a rental analysis based on nearby leased homes is more accurate.

Can my HOA stop me from renting my Fleming Island home?

An HOA's recorded declaration can set leasing rules such as minimum lease terms or tenant registration. Florida limits how rules adopted after July 1, 2021 apply to owners who already held title, but existing rules still apply. Read your documents before you list.

Do property managers offer military discounts in Fleming Island?

Some do. Cool Realty publishes a 9% management fee for active-duty and retired military. Ask each company whether it offers military pricing or PCS support.

Where are evictions filed for Fleming Island rentals?

In Clay County Court at the courthouse in Green Cove Springs. The tenant has 5 business days to respond after service, and the Clay County Sheriff's Office charges $90 to execute a writ of possession.

Choosing Your Fleming Island Property Manager

The right manager for a Fleming Island rental prices from nearby leased homes, handles your HOA's leasing rules, screens every applicant the same way, inspects on a stated schedule and shows every fee in writing. Use the comparison, scorecard and questions above with two or three companies before you decide.

Own a rental property in Fleming Island? Find out what your home could rent for and whether professional management is right for you. Contact Cool Realty LLC at (904) 602-5555 for a Free Rental Analysis, or visit our Fleming Island property management page.

Sources

  • Zillow Rental Manager — ZIP 32003 market trends (updated Nov. 9, 2026).
  • U.S. Census Bureau QuickFacts — Fleming Island CDP, Florida.
  • Clay County Clerk of Court — Evictions.
  • Florida Statutes §83.49, §83.512, §83.682 and §720.306.
  • Company pages checked Nov. 16, 2026: propertymanagerjacksonville.com (Cool Realty); belonghome.com (Belong, Fleming Island); homeriver.com (HomeRiver Group, Orange Park) and awning.com (Fleming Island listing); thumbtack.com (PMI Davis Realty).
back